Bare Bones Mafia

[Dyson]

IF YOU ARE NOT PLAYING IN THE GAME, PLEASE DO NOT POST IN THIS THREAD.


ALL PLAYERS MUST READ!

Things to remember:

1) A full writeup of the rules can be found here. (http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Main_Page)

2) When you vote to lynch, please do so by saying Vote: [Player] in bold. If you wish to change your vote, please say Change Vote: [Player] instead. Voting "Nobody" is a valid vote; if a majority votes for 'nobody' then nobody will be lynched and we'll move on to the Night phase.

3) If your role says you *may* PM me a target, you don't have to do anything at night. Even so, it'll speed things along quite a bit if you'd still just send me a PM saying "Not using my [whatever] power tonight, thanks."

4) If your role says you *must* PM me a target, and you do not, I'll pick one randomly. Or, perhaps, not-so-randomly. Don't blame me if you target someone who kills you.

5) You may NOT send a PM to anyone about this game unless your role explicitly says you can. This is cheating. Nor can you discuss this game in any other thread than this.

6) Do NOT edit your posts in this thread. This is cheating.

7) Please do not copy-and-paste anything from any PM I send you to the thread. This is also cheating.

8) Please do not post in this thread after you are killed. This, too, is cheating and can ruin the game if done wrong.

9) Please do not post pictures in this thread, it will get very tedious if it's clogged up with crap.

10) These rules were originally written by Chairdriver. Kudos to the man!

11) Remember, it's just a game. You will get paranoid, you will be stabbed in the back by someone, you will see somebody do or say something stupid and want to smack them. Just breathe deep and relax. If things get out of hand, we do have a mod playing who will forcibly remind you to chill out if needed. It hasn't happened yet, and we'd all like to keep it that way.

11) Send your PM regarding your power to Dyson.

12) Absolutely NO talking during Night. I will come down harshly upon those who I deem to be breaking this rule on a case by case basis.

13) Remember, have fun!

Participants - 34 (17 is a majority) (Placing in alphabetical order now :P)
Beggilax
Brian Mcoy
Coolness Bears
Cube
darksnowman
Domjcg
Eenuh
Esequiel
Fandango
Gizmo
Haggis
Jamba
jayseven
Jonnas
Lazyboy
Maase
Maddog
MoogleViper
mr-paul
Mundi
nightwolf
Nintendohnut
Oxigen_Waste
Raining_Again
scubahood
Shino
Strider
Tellyn
The Fish
thunderer
Vicar
VoLcOm
Wildo
Zell
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The town was having a quiet day. All around, people were milling in that quiet lifestyle way people do. But something happened. Something went terribly wrong..

In the Mayor's office, Dyson sat down to his evening tea to over watch his people milling around in that quiet lifestyle way that people do, and he was happy. He sat down with a cup of tea and opened his draw. From out of it, he picked up a Werther's Original, a favourite of his. As he popped it in to his mouth and took a swig of his tea, he noticed Letty streaking along the village green for what seemed like no apparant reason, which subsequently forced Dyson to choke. The choking became more violent, and eventually...

Dyson is dead. He was the Mayor. He ran the town and kept it under control, and everybody loved him, because he is was awesome.

As the news spread around the town, some people were shocked to hear their great leader had fallen. Some people cried, some people continued to quietly mill around, and some...viewed this as the opportunity they'd been waiting for.

Without that pesky Dyson fellow around, the Mafia could easily take control of the village. All they'd need to do is overpower them in manpower and they'd have it in their hands, along with access to Dyson's private old funds, of about £32.92. The money was to be used for renovation purposes, but in the Mafia's hands, who knows what kinda crazy stunts they'll pull?!

Everybody could feel the chill in the air. Until today everything in the town was perfect. But not anymore. The town, which consisted of mostly useless quiet milling types, a number of private investigators who spent most of their days investigating why the town was so boring, and a sprinkling of doctors, who spent most of their time diagnosing the town statues, organized a daily forum, and sat down to talk about who to push out of this village next for some reason.

What happens next is up to you..

------

Day 1 starts now.

If you have not recieved a PM, you are a townie! It is your objective to get rid of the Mafia threat before they get rid of you. You have Doctors and Investigators at your disposal, but nobody is really sure who they are except themselves, because they've never had to be used before. You win when the entire Mafia is wiped out.

If you have recieved a PM, you know your role.

Good luck everyone!

[mr-paul]

OOh this sounds interesting!

Good luck everyone!

Vote: no lynch

[Raining_again]

Woo lets get this parteh started!

Vote: No lynch!

[Tellyn]

Excellent write up Mr. Dyson.

Vote: No Lynch

[DomJcg]

Vote: no lynch

Lets get our game on :)

[Jamba]

Yay, more mafia!

Vote: No Lynch

[Nintendohnut]

Wooop! I'm excited already!

Vote: No Lynch

[chairdriver]

Vote : Haggis

The town is better off not having people that never contribute.

[Dyson]

Vote : Haggis

The town is better off not having people that never contribute.


I'd count the vote but you're not playing in this game as you said you'd rather not take part, ie, you never signed up.

Sorry. : peace:

[Tellyn]

Oh dear...

[chairdriver]

LOL!

I swear I saw my name on the list.


*Is a crazy tourist passing through*

[Dyson]

You probably saw it on Rule 10. :P

[Cube]

Yay. Another game.

Vote: No Lynch

[Esequiel]

You never sent me my role?

[DomJcg]

Day 1 starts now.

If you have not recieved a PM, you are a townie! It is your objective to get rid of the Mafia threat before they get rid of you. You have Doctors and Investigators at your disposal, but nobody is really sure who they are except themselves, because they've never had to be used before. You win when the entire Mafia is wiped out.

If you have recieved a PM, you know your role.

Good luck everyone!

---------
Read the rules townie...

[Nintendohnut]

You never sent me my role?

This is either really, really, REALLY stupid, or an attempt to be really, really clever (or a joke....but I doubt it as it's not funny :) ). Not sure which at this point.

[Shino]

I don't remember that well how the other bare bones mafia game went, but I'm curious to see the paranoia.

Vote: No Lynch

[Cube]

I don't remember that well how the other bare bones mafia game went, but I'm curious to see the paranoia.

That's because this is the first.

[Shino]

That's because this is the first.

Really? Than why do people keep going on about how fun it was?

[Jamba]

Really? Than why do people keep going on about how fun it was?

Umm like where? Have you been drinking again...?

[Gizmo]

Esequiel's a townie then...

Might wanna read the write up :smile:

Vote:No Lynch

[Tellyn]

He's talking about the original mafia game(s) by Chairdriver.

[Shino]

Am I going crazy? Do I have an imaginary forum?

I'm pretty sure this game was created with the intention of bringing back the fun of that (imaginary) game.

[thunderer]

R.I.P Our beloved Mayor Dyson.

Vote: No lynch

[MadDog]

No Lynch..

[Zell]

Should be interesting.

Vote: No lynch

[Esequiel]

*wink* *wink*

Vote Domjcg for being a smart arse

[Dyson]

Votes: (17 is a majority)
---
No Lynch (12): mr-paul, Raining_Again, Tellyn, Domjcg, Jamba, Nintendohnut, Cube, Shino, Gizmo, thunderer, MadDog, Zell

Domjcg (1): Esequiel

[DomJcg]

Votes: (17 is a majority)

Domjcg (1): Esequiel

woooww, i can't believe it, it's like the first time someones voted for someone literially based nothing

=[

[The fish]

Vote: No lynch

*insert generic joke about "poor No Lynch" here*

[Raining_again]

woooww, i can't believe it, it's like the first time someones voted for someone literially based nothing

=[

He was only saying what (I reckon) a lot of us were thinking.

[DomJcg]

He was only saying what (I reckon) a lot of us were thinking.

Meh, i guess, *reads the post*

I dislike rule 10! it's not a rule! anyways...back to not lynching...

[Eenuh]

Whoo, a new game to keep me from getting any school work done! Awesome! =P

Vote: No lynch

[chairdriver]

Meh, i guess, *reads the post*

I dislike rule 10! it's not a rule! anyways...back to not lynching...

Rule 10 is an essential rule :heh:

*Hops onto a bus to the next town being terrorised by a mafia*

[Jonnas]

First of all, good luck!
Second, Shino, you're not going crazy. Some people confused the concept, and that's why you're confused.

Anyway, seeing as there's virtually no way of us getting info without talking, I'll follow chair's foosteps, and vote for someone at random (although with some reasoning).

Vote: Haggis

[Jamba]

(although with some reasoning).

Vote: Haggis

Care to share bear?

[Nintendohnut]

I've just realised that the nights in this game are going to be really, really quick, because there are only about 15 people sending in PMs rather than 35.

Well, depending on the people of course... But this will ruin Esequiel's "Day counter" thing on the progress thread, this will have to get a special mention!

[Mundi]

Vote: No Lynch

[Beggilax]

Vote: Mundi

I need no reason

[Dyson]

Votes: (17 is a majority)
---
No Lynch (15): mr-paul, Raining_Again, Tellyn, Domjcg, Jamba, Nintendohnut, Cube, Shino, Gizmo, thunderer, MadDog, Zell, The fish, Eenuh, Mundi

Domjcg (1): Esequiel

Haggis (1): Jonnas

Mundi (1): Beggilax

[Jonnas]

Care to share bear?

The same reasoning as chair, really. Haggis quit my game because he said he didn't have time.

I'm just saying Haggis as a good chance of not participating, so why not vote him, anyway? Talking is all we can do, right now.

And I know that if Haggis is innocent, your eyes will be on me, and we'll talk more. See, that's some progress, right there.

[Jamba]

Fair point. I wonder if we should actually have some kind of Mafia black list to stop people from joining up and not participating?

[DomJcg]

The same reasoning as chair, really. Haggis quit my game because he said he didn't have time.

I'm just saying Haggis as a good chance of not participating, so why not vote him, anyway? Talking is all we can do, right now.

And I know that if Haggis is innocent, your eyes will be on me, and we'll talk more. See, that's some progress, right there.

Yes, but as you say, at the same time, your saying that it's more likely you will get lynched if haggis dies, and since theres only good and evil in this game, then he is more likely to be good than anything else, so it doesn't benefit you in anyway to be voting off haggis at this very moment.

[wildo]

Sorry for showing up so late to the party.

Vote:No Lynch

[Mundi]

I say that we wait until the game progresses until we start lynching people due to inactiveness on the first day of the day..

Sound good?

[LazyBoy]

MUNDI IS MAFIA!!!

Just playing. No Lynch

[Mundi]

Dammit man! Why do you always have to blow my cover!

[Dyson]

Votes: (17 is a majority)
---
No Lynch (17): mr-paul, Raining_Again, Tellyn, Domjcg, Jamba, Nintendohnut, Cube, Shino, Gizmo, thunderer, MadDog, Zell, The fish, Eenuh, Mundi, LazyBoy, Wildo

Domjcg (1): Esequiel

Haggis (1): Jonnas

Mundi (1): Beggilax

---

A majority has been reached. After the first day, the townsfolk decided that quietly milling around a little more would be the best option. Nobody suffers...yet.

Day 1 has ended. Night 1 will now start. Please send in all targets ASAP.

And as a side note, I ask you to refer back to Rule 12 : peace:

[Oxigen_Waste]

Dyson... herm... I didn't get a role. =S

[VoLcOm]

i din´t get a role :(

[Eenuh]

People, please read the first post properly. X3

*sleeps*

[Dyson]

http://www.terminally-incoherent.com/img/facepalm.jpeg

[Gizmo]

http://i195.photobucket.com/albums/z319/H4ACN/facepalm.jpg

[Oxigen_Waste]

Shit. So I die in the first day in the forum mafia and pretty much kill myself on the first day of this one. Go me!!! =/ Damn. I didn't read the first post at all.

[Gizmo]

I woulda thought you'd be less of a target if you had no power personally, but I'll stfu as its night.

[Dyson]

Night 1 is over.

---

Throughout the night, there were several reports of shuffling around. Unfortunately, the R&B fan of the village had his headphones turned up too loud; and the mafia were trying to sleep. (Fair enough, right?)

"YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUU are no more!"

scubahood is dead. He was a good guy.

He was found hanging from his headphones which were surprisingly sturdy, in some barn.

Elsewhere, detectives detected and protectors protected.

---

Day 2 starts..now.

[Tellyn]

YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOU legend Dyson. :heh:

I suppose I should ask, anyone got any leads?

[nightwolf]

Sorry I didn't post yesterday guys, had my theory test and whatnot ^.^

[Jamba]

Lol at the funnies! No info from me i'm afriad.

[Raining_again]

Neh, nothing here.

[mr-paul]

Absolutely nothing here either.
This game is gonna be hard...

[Eenuh]

No info here either sadly.

[MoogleViper]

What eenuh said.

[mr-paul]

I have a feeling this game is not gonna go very fast. Do we have any investigators? It sucks a bit, cos even if we do, they are more likely to investigate a good player. And if they come out with info, they will definitely be targeted by the mafia.

I'm confused over what to do and how on earth anyone is gonna win this.

[Eenuh]

I have a feeling this game is not gonna go very fast. Do we have any investigators? It sucks a bit, cos even if we do, they are more likely to investigate a good player. And if they come out with info, they will definitely be targeted by the mafia.

I'm confused over what to do and how on earth anyone is gonna win this.
Well if they do come out with information, there's always the protectors who can go and protect them. Thing is we don't know how many there are of each role and how many good and bad guys there are.

[Tellyn]

The protectors don't have to come out and reveal themselves, so the investigators would be pretty safe, I'd say.

[mr-paul]

Well I guess then we wait until an investigator finds someone evil. And then, protect them. This is gonna take ages.

[Maase]

I ask everyone to talk in the day, i think we should lynch the ones who don't talk, we will not need them anyway.

[MadDog]

No info here either sadly.

..........

[Raining_again]

An early night for a few of us then....

:zzz:

[Zell]

Just posting to confirm I'm not laying low. I have no info though.

[The fish]

I know slightly less than everyone else - hosting a Mafia makes you see everyone by their roles in your own game. :heh:

[DomJcg]

I know slightly less than everyone else - hosting a Mafia makes you see everyone by their roles in your own game. :heh:

:( it's so true, i'm in a dazed confused state at the moment.

[Esequiel]

Vote haggis

He generally adds nothing to most games.

[Slaggis]

Jesus, Esiqual. I left the other game and took part in the other, I do apologise. Get some real evidence rather than randomly voting will you?

If I have something relavent to post, that might help, I post. If I don't, I hang back and see whats going on. Is there anything wrong with that?

[wildo]

Sorry guys no info here either. Surely somebody knows something?

[LazyBoy]

La li la li

[uəʌəsʎɐɾ]

Vote haggis

He generally adds nothing to most games.

Haggis is a Pro mafia player, so leave 'im alone.

Postin' to say I know nuffink.

Vote: No Lynch for now. Speeding up the days might give the mafia more chances, but it gives the investigators/protectors amongst us to do their shizzle too. A body for info? Sure, when there's a kajillion people playing.

[Shino]

I don't think you guys have yet grasped how to play this game. There won't be any information. There's probably 1 cop and 1 doctor, and we can't rely on them.

I don't have any big suspicion over anyone. Yet.

[Dyson]

---

The train doors open. As one member of the village, nightwolf, leaves for better things (probably searching for an ear piercing specialist, nobody in this town is adventurous enough to open one), another steps off. He had seen these kinds of towns before, and had plenty of experience with this kind of thing. People noticed his arrival, he wasn't unknown around these parts..

--
nightwolf has left the game, to be directly replaced by chairdriver.
--

Day 2 continues.

[Brian Mcoy]

Mcoy only just realized he's actually playing this game as Mcoy just looked at the forum by chance, Mcoy will look over the thread and decide who to vote etc.

Mcoy vote Nobody for now

[Dyson]

---
Votes: (17 is a majority)

No Lynch (2): jayseven, Brian Mcoy
Haggis (1): Esequiel
thunderer (1): chairdriver
---

[chairdriver]

Yes, Mr. CD is in the house.

Hmmm... I might as well do this, seeing as I'll probably get killed tonight and the info will be lost:

Nightwolf was a cop (thus I'm a cop), and she checked out Shino last night. He's good.

You're probably screaming at me "Why are you outing yourself now!?!" but in my experience it's better when the doctors know who to protect, and it's good to cross people off the suspect list.


So yeah, protection would be nice.

In the mean time, let's actually get something done.


Vote : thunderer

Chosen at random from a list of people who have barely posted. It's really pointless going no lynch, since that way we have no chance of lynching a mafia member, whereas with a random vote we have an x/30 chance of lynching a mafia member (where x is the number of mafia members).

Also voting patterns can give us a big clue to who is mafia.

[Jamba]

Ahhhhh finally, info!

Yeah, that logic does carry. Sooner we get the cops under protection then the quicker we can start to root out the mafia in safety.

[Maase]

34 characters, 5 mafia's, one doctor and one cop, i would really like to know how the hell the townies gonna win, if we continue to have people who just wants information.


Oh, and Chairdriver,i think you messed things up to you, there's problably only one protector (i don't know if its the Doc or the Cop to protect, so i call him protector), and now that you're with the target on your neck, the protector will have to allways help you.

There may be times when its needed to protect two guys.

I just hope you don't screwit to us.

But anyway, i think that a kinda-suicidal idea to help things to move is to Lynch Shino, if he's in fact good, then we can trust Chairdriver? Or something like that?

[chairdriver]

But anyway, i think that a kinda-suicidal idea to help things to move is to Lynch Shino, if he's in fact good, then we can trust Chairdriver? Or something like that?

Yeah, we could do that, but it seems extremely counter productive.

[Nintendohnut]

Don't mean to sound crazy....but why do we trust Chairdriver?

For all we know he's said "I'm an investigator, *picks name at random*...scubahood is good!"

Not saying this is true, but it means he gets protection from now on, when in actual fact he may just be one of us wanting to survive and win...

Just an idea.

[Shino]

Yeah...

Vote: Maase

Not fucking around this time.

[chairdriver]

Night 1 is over.


Elsewhere, detectives detected and protectors protected.

---

Day 2 starts..now.

I got the feeling there's more than one cop, and more than one doctor, since Dyson used the plural.

[Jamba]

But anyway, i think that a kinda-suicidal idea to help things to move is to Lynch Shino, if he's in fact good, then we can trust Chairdriver? Or something like that?

That's a rediculous idea. We have one chance a day to kill a mafia member by voting on a complete random and you want to go kill a good guy? That's 0% chance that we'll get a mafia. Shino could be a doctor or another cop and killing him isn't going to help anybody.

[chairdriver]

Yeah, it's probably best to get rid of someone who wants to lynch someone who has just been cleared as a townie.

Vote : maase

[Maase]

Hum.. you're right, Chairdriver, im happy by that, just 1 cop and 1 doctor would be impossible.

Still, i still don't see a way to believe in you a hundred %, e continue to believe that we have to find a way to see the truth.

Shino, im really sorry pal, but don't worry, they will not problably accept my idea anyways.

Also, if Chairdriver would be from the Mafia and Shino too, a great idea would be to do as they did, that would give instant protection to two guys from Mafia.

But anyway, if we don't use that way, any suggestions about what to do next?

[Jamba]

But anyway, if we don't use that way, any suggestions about what to do next?

We've got nothing else to go on. We should lynch someone though and who's to say that your not mafia? You seem awfully quick to suggest such an extreme measure as killing a townie just to check chair out.

[Raining_again]

Don't mean to sound crazy....but why do we trust Chairdriver?

For all we know he's said "I'm an investigator, *picks name at random*...scubahood is good!"

Not saying this is true, but it means he gets protection from now on, when in actual fact he may just be one of us wanting to survive and win...

Just an idea.

You say that, but in that case why do we trust anyone? We'd be running round in paranoid circles. He'll tell us someone is evil and if we lynch and we'll find out then. There's no other way to verify anyone...

Also Maase, would you ever learn? You jump the gun far too much.

Vote: Maase

[Maase]

Hum... Also, if Chairdriver isn't in fact from Mafia, is it possible that he is only doing this to protect himself till the end of the game?

I didn't get one thing, are there neutrals in this game? If so, maybe Chairdriver is from one of them?

I continue to believe there's something weird about this, but i'l soon find out if im right or not :)

[Gizmo]

Since otherwise this game is going to be quite slow;

Vote:Maase

For being extremely annoying in these games and often counter productive for us.

[Jamba]

I'm off to bed. I'll vot for someone tomorrow but nothing for now...


I continue to believe there's something weird about this, but i'l soon find out if im right or not :)

...although this kinda stuff makes me want to now. Watch yourself. These kind of vague comments make you a target, you sound like some pathetic horoscope writer who's begging for people to believe them.

You're the only suspicious person we have atm imo.

[Eenuh]

Hum... Also, if Chairdriver isn't in fact from Mafia, is it possible that he is only doing this to protect himself till the end of the game?

I didn't get one thing, are there neutrals in this game? If so, maybe Chairdriver is from one of them?

I continue to believe there's something weird about this, but i'l soon find out if im right or not :)

As far as I know no neutrals in this. Plus if Chairdriver keeps giving us information, at one point we -will- find out if he is right or wrong. Honestly, it would be foolish of him to say he's an investigator if he really wasn't cause now all eyes are on him and he would get lynched if his info turns out to be wrong.

[Maase]

4 votes in 17, i still have 13 votes left before being Lynched, wich gives me a fair ammount of 15 hours to think, i ask you guys to think with me while you lynch me.

As i said before, there's the possibility of killing Shino to discover if he's in fact from Mafia, and if he is, Lynch Chairdriver the night later.

There's also the possibility to ask any Investigator (because there are suposedly more than 1, right?) to investigate Chairdriver or Shino, they are the two trumph cards of the Townies, that can be used later.

As this is a Barebones mafia, there aren't problably any burnerers in game, wich leads me to think that we will discover the alligment of Every Single player in this game when he dies, one think i ask is to remember what i said about Shino and Chairdriver.

Hum, we should do more of this games, we are completely against the odds

[Gizmo]

4 votes in 17, i still have 13 votes left before being Lynched, wich gives me a fair ammount of 15 hours to think, i ask you guys to think with me while you lynch me.

As i said before, there's the possibility of killing Shino to discover if he's in fact from Mafia, and if he is, Lynch Chairdriver the night later.

There's also the possibility to ask any Investigator (because there are suposedly more than 1, right?) to investigate Chairdriver or Shino, they are the two trumph cards of the Townies, that can be used later.

As this is a Barebones mafia, there aren't problably any burnerers in game, wich leads me to think that we will discover the alligment of Every Single player in this game when he dies, one think i ask is to remember what i said about Shino and Chairdriver.

Hum, we should do more of this games, we are completely against the odds

If we want another investigator to check out Chair, then he needs to come forward and reveal himself too. Then, you'll moan about how we don't know if THEY can be trusted, and want someone to investigate them.

[Zell]

While I'm not overly enthusiastic about lynching Maase, we need to get someone lynched everyday. So...

Vote: Maase

[Maase]

You're right.

And the problem wouldn't be just that, we would be back to the Square 1, cause we could trust as must as Chairdriver.

Hum, Eenuh is right, tough, i guess we will find out about Chairdriver soon enough. But i still think that something feels weird in the whole thing.

So... what can we do now?

[Cube]

As i said before, there's the possibility of killing Shino to discover if he's in fact from Mafia, and if he is, Lynch Chairdriver the night later.


Even if he is playing us, I doubt he'll start off by saying that someone who is evil is good. It would be too obvious and label both of them when Chairdriver steers us wrong.

Chairdriver: are there any circumstances in which your information could be wrong, or in which your power doesn't work? Or is this game too "simplistic" for stuff like that?

[Jamba]

Screw it. Maase you keep talking and talking and the more you do, the less I trust you. We have no info really (until we find out about chairdriver) and we need to lynch someone. Learn when to keep quiet.

Vote: Maase.

[Maase]

Nop, im thinking and expressing my ideas in the game, something that all of you should do, instead of waiting for the Mafia to kill you.

Also, im a Doctor, so the ones who will be screwed are you, not me.

This is a warning, believe me, you don't want a Doctor killed in a Bare Bones Mafia.


Now, continuing in my toughts:

-I still think that there are only three possible reasons for the sudden movement of Chairdriver, right when he started the game:

A) Chairdriver is defending himself so he can remain as winner in Townie, this is the most probable one.

B) Chairdriver is in fact a Cop, but i think that it was stupid to say that Shino is good, and that now the Doctors will have more one to protect instantly. This combined with the fact that one doctor will be gone tonight, makes me think that Chairdriver made a bad move.

C) Chairdriver is from Mafia, he's either defending Shino, who's from Mafia too, or telling members who aren't from Mafia, that are most problably good, this would be a great move in my opinion.


Hum... im stuck.

Vote: No Lynch

Someone to add something?





Ups, sorry for the Double Post, didn't see the Cube Post:

Cube: You're right, that's what i was thinkin right now in Option C

But, i don't believe there are false investigators in one Bare Bones Mafia game, i tought there were only Mafia members, some Cops, some Doctors and nothing else.

That's what i tought of Bare Bones Mafia

[Jonnas]

Experience has shown us that Maase is never evil. He's just easy to lynch.
In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Maase was a "must be lynched to win" role in FmkII.

Some things need to be said, though. This game is "Bare Bones". Just a simple Investigator (or two), and just a simple Protector (or two) is all we have for help. No quirky twists in those roles. Even the mafiosos are powerless (sans the whole killing thing). Talking will define this game.

Shino is not 100% good. He could be the Godfather, remember.

Anyway, because chair is right about this:

Vote: Thunderer

[Eenuh]

Yeah well if you don't get lynched now, you'll get nightkilled for sure anyway. -____-;

[Maase]

Jonnas, im not evil, i can assure you that.

Im a doctor, and as you said, this is a game where we have to talk and express ideas, not a game where we sit and wait for information in our table.

THING, PEOPLE!!!

Camon, we are having a huge debate, instead of insulting me, let's start thinking about anything we can.








I'l protect myself (if that's possible)

If that isn't possible, then i'l expect help from another Doctor :)

To the doctors out there, i promisse i'l protect Chairdriver (grrr), please protect me

[Jonnas]

For fuck's sake...Maase, doctors are the mafia's top priority.

You won't die from lynching, you'll die from Mafia. Do you realise that you could be our only doctor?

[Maase]

Night 1 is over.

---

Throughout the night, there were several reports of shuffling around. Unfortunately, the R&B fan of the village had his headphones turned up too loud; and the mafia were trying to sleep. (Fair enough, right?)

"YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUU are no more!"

scubahood is dead. He was a good guy.

He was found hanging from his headphones which were surprisingly sturdy, in some barn.

Elsewhere, detectives detected and protectors protected.

---

Day 2 starts..now.

This and the fact there are 37 freakin players, leads me to believie that there are more Doctors out there :)

[Shino]

THING, PEOPLE!!!

Hahahaha!

The doctor thing, I think you're lying to cover up for what you messed up.

[Eenuh]

This and the fact there are 37 freakin players, leads me to believie that there are more Doctors out there :)

Yeah but now one of them needs to constantly be protecting you, while they could've been out protecting other people. =/
Plus it's impossible for them to know who is protecting who, so it's possible they might all be focusing on you now. >.<;

[Mundi]

This and the fact there are 37 freakin players, leads me to believie that there are more Doctors out there :)

Yeah and we need every single one of them.

I can´t really say that your lying or telling the truth but judging from other games you always have a convenient lie that makes you seem too important to be lynched.
Not gonna vote yet, just saying I think your lying

[Maase]

Damn, i commited the same damn mistake that i said Chairdriver not to do.

Eenuh, i'l guess the doctors will have to play by instinct.

Shino, im not lying, i am in fact one of your protectors, the one who can save you guys from death, and i made everything not to tell i was a doctor, but you would lynch me, so i had to try this.

[The fish]

Because I agree with euthanasia for people who blatantly want to die:

Vote: Maase

[Maase]

Vote: Maase

Whatever

[Jonnas]

The fact that Maase is so easily getting votes just leads me to believe he's not a mafioso, and the mafiosos will just try to lynch him, because it's that damn easy. If he was a mafioso, I'm sure his buddies would defend him.

If he's evil, I'll eat my own hat.

[Mundi]

The fact that Maase is so easily getting votes just leads me to believe he's not a mafioso, and the mafiosos will just try to lynch him, because it's that damn easy. If he was a mafioso, I'm sure his buddies would defend him.

If he's evil, I'll eat my own hat.

I agree.. people seem to be lynching him for being himself...

I think that the person who started this charade should be investigated tonight.

[Maase]

Hey!!! What do you mean by lynching me for being mysef? :'(

But i can assure you im not a Mafioso.

As i asked before, i will protect Chairdriver, an i hope someone protects me, please?

[Shino]

I agree.. people seem to be lynching him for being himself...

I think that the person who started this charade should be investigated tonight.

Who, me? Again?

[Mundi]

Who, me? Again?

Your not the only person to start this....

[Shino]

Well, anyway:

If he was a mafioso, I'm sure his buddies would defend him.

The fact that Maase is so easily getting votes just leads me to believe he's not a mafioso, and the mafiosos will just try to lynch him, because it's that damn easy.If he was a mafioso, I'm sure his buddies would defend him.

If he's evil, I'll eat my own hat.

I agree.. people seem to be lynching him for being himself...

I think that the person who started this charade should be investigated tonight.

[Mundi]

Are we playing this game now?
I must be connected to him because I disagree with what is going on.
A fool proof strategy that comes up in every game and is always correct.
Right?

If we´re gonna play like that we might just as well lynch people based on a dice roll for all the good it might too.
It´s because of stuff like this that these games have way too much sheep voting and people keeping silent the whole because if they agree with the wrong person they might be stamped as a bad guy.

[Shino]

This is the only way to play this game (specifically), our words are our actions and I expect people to think what I am based on what I say.

I'm not accusing anyone, I'm just pointing out.

[Mundi]

So if Maase ends up being good we can lynch you because you were wrong?
And if you end up being good you can lynch me for being wrong and then you can lynch the person who pushed the point to lynch me for being wrong.

People also need to incorporate that (shockingly) people can be wrong and lynching people just because of something like that is just lazy work.

But if you can take that fact add some inconsistencies to that player, faulty stories and exposed lies then we have something to work with.

And I´m not saying that Maase is either good or evil I´m just saying that people are rushing it too much.

[Shino]

The more proof the better, but we wait every time for 1 or 2 investigators to tell us what to do. I admit it is too early to make any pattern and I'm lynching Maase because its funny.

[Mundi]

As funny as it is too lynch Maase I don´t really want to give the mafia a free kill if he ends up being good

[Shino]

I don't know that he isn't. He's as good as anyone else and jumped on the most illogical idea of killing the only certified good guy.

[LazyBoy]

Nothing in this game is certified. This is a different type of game. We can't play it liked we play the other ones, evidence isn't good enough. If we're going to find the baddies we can't look at what they're saying, that's not enough, we have to study how they're saying it. We've played enough games now that people have patterns, they act a certain way when they're guilty. Look at how they act, how they respond to accusations and how they make them. Do they plead under pressure or get angry? This is how the good will emerge victorious.

And most important of all, don't trust anyone.

[Esequiel]

Well i know for a fact that there is more than 1 cop. How do i know?

Dyson... you sent me a PM by mistake, telling me i was investigated. :)

So either chair is lying or theres more than 1.

Also change vote Thundererer

[Gizmo]

What's the evidence against Thunderer?

I'm sticking with my vote for Maase. Whether he's evil or not, let's be honest, he's a nuisance.

[Eenuh]

Well even though Maase can be annoying, it'd be silly to vote someone off who might be good.
If you want to vote for someone, pick a person who rarely contributes in these games instead.

[Jamba]

Why are people changing their votes now? This makes no sense at all... both thunderer and Maase are as suspicious as each other as we know nothing atm. And why, in this game where we have very little info, are we threatening to vote off people who don't participate as much? Surely someone being irritating is just as good a reason?

[Esequiel]

I think a game such as this should be alot shorter in days and nights. Its pretty obvious were not going to make a lynch today, may aswell end the day and let another goody be killed off at night >.>

[Nintendohnut]

Better than that kill off one in the day just because he's annoying (Maase, or anyone else) and then let the mafia kill again tonight... I just don't see the point in voting someone off without evidence, it's more likely we'll be killing a townie than a mafia member so we'll just be helping the mafia out.

Maybe I'm thinking to softly, but I think it's better to kill someone when we know they are evil rather than just guessing, because otherwise we're just giving mafia free kills.

[Gizmo]

We'll never get anywhere like that Dohnut. We need to take risks.

I admit that at this point there is not really anything to suggest Maase is evil, but look back at previous games - all he has done is take our attention off of the other issues.

[Jonnas]

I think a game such as this should be alot shorter in days and nights. Its pretty obvious were not going to make a lynch today, may aswell end the day and let another goody be killed off at night >.>

If anything, the days should be longer. Talking is all we have, let's not shorten it.

Better than that kill off one in the day just because he's annoying (Maase, or anyone else) and then let the mafia kill again tonight... I just don't see the point in voting someone off without evidence, it's more likely we'll be killing a townie than a mafia member so we'll just be helping the mafia out.

Maybe I'm thinking to softly, but I think it's better to kill someone when we know they are evil rather than just guessing, because otherwise we're just giving mafia free kills.

The thing is, it will be hard to have any kind of evidence against the bad guys. We must base ourselves on suspicion and paranoia.

And if someone doesn't talk, it doesn't vote. And that's even more useless than an annoying person.

[darksnowman]

Nothing to report.

I'm almost tempted to vote Haggis, but I won't... unless there is some real evidence?! I'll see how things develop between thunderer and maase before I cast my vote.

[Maase]

Guys, most of you are playing this game the wrong way. (And now, being the game a BARE BONES Mafia, its gonna be impossible to the Townies if we continue to play like this).

We have to think with logic, we have to play smartly, and i can guarantee that Gizmo is being the perfect example of not playing this game with logic.

I may be a botter (watevah), but i can be very useful to the town, this without counting that im not being a bother, im trying to think about the previous situation.

If you guys want to maintain shut up, waiting for someone to give information or someone to say something you don't agree with, or even worse, for someone to vote, so you can vote the same player later without any logical reason, then continue to play that game.

I made my mistakes in the past, i know, but this time im not making any mistakes, the one making them are most of you.

Another thing i hate is to lynch players who aren't playing, don't worry about them, if they aren't playing, they can't be dangerous to us, and can be useful to us, after all, the more there are, the less chances are for the Mafia to find a useful member to the Mafia with so many members.

Also, there's a chance that later, they'l come to play the game, forgoting about him and remembering, or something like that.

So, back to the information we had earlier, we still have some time, we haven't anyone to lynch, so we should maintain quiet in this day, so, anything to think about now? I may forgotten something

[darksnowman]

Players might not look like they are playing, but they could still be getting their PM's in at night and killing us off. You're right that we need to use logic, but its a bit early for that because there are no patterns to look for, etc. Our best bet at such an early stage will be to lynch someone based on whatever info can be pieced together and hope for the best.

[uəʌəsʎɐɾ]

I still believe that we're all going about these games in vaguely the wrong way. Because of the sheer number of people playing, it may be absolutely ages until any detectives get any information, and even then we'll have the whole ooh but can we trust YOU?! debate with them for a day and a half, where they end up saying "well if I'm wrong then lynch me tomorrow"...

Not everyone is going to survive. The quicker nights come around the quicker the detectives can get to work. When we have no info what use is it to bicker!

[Maase]

Hum, you're forgetting the fact we have info, the fact that Chairdriver says that Shino is good, and what im discussing is if Chairdriver is indeed right.

But okay, we are discussing a stupid point, are you saying that we have nothing to do, so we will have to take the damage?

Darksnowman is right, tough, i just hope Thunderer is not a Cop or Doctor.

Vote: Thunderer

[Mundi]

Why are people voting for Thunderer?
I fail too see the point.

[MoogleViper]

I'm getting lynch hungry.

Basically we spend too much faffing around and not enough time lynching. The townies don't have night powers like before so we need to use the daytime. i say a random/whoever is more annoying lynch.

[Slaggis]

Other than being annoying, I see no reason to vote for maase...unless I've missed something crucial. Same for thunderer, as far as I'm aware.

[Gizmo]

Other than being annoying, I see no reason to vote for maase...unless I've missed something crucial. Same for thunderer, as far as I'm aware.

That is exactly the reason to vote for Maase. He makes far too many mistakes and side tracks real discussion all too often.

Logical or not, we have nothing better to do.

[Slaggis]

That is exactly the reason to vote for Maase. He makes far too many mistakes and side tracks real discussion all too often.

Logical or not, we have nothing better to do.

Actually, I hadn't thought about it like that. That makes sense, so:

Vote: Maase

[Jamba]

Please can we get this day over with, it's dragging really badly and we are getting no where. Surely the night will bring some info?

[Maase]

Forget about info, damnit.

And Haggis, you problably missed that im a Doctor, you are making a big mistake by voting me.

And Gizmo, i didn't made any mistake yet, you are making the mistake, not me.

[chairdriver]

Why on earth did you out yourself as the doctor?

1) It makes me believe you less, since a real doctor would never out himself.

2) You'll get killed tonight, for sure.


I'm happy to vote thunderer aswell, since he's barely contributed in past games.

[Maase]

Because, if i didn't, i would be already lynched, wich would be the same thing (you know as well as i do that its true), its not my fault that you suspect me with everything i said, i didn't screw you, you screwed yourselves. Maybe next time you will not suspect of me so easily.

Also, there's the chance that there's another doctor, and i already told to the doctor to protect me, while i protect Chairdriver.

Now, its a matter of Hope.

[MadDog]

Why are we lynching Maase? :S
I dont understand what he has done :S

[chairdriver]

Hmmm...

While I don't really believe maase's claim, I'm going to change vote: thunderer. At least maase is posting.

[Tellyn]

Because, if i didn't, i would be already lynched, wich would be the same thing (you know as well as i do that its true), its not my fault that you suspect me with everything i said, i didn't screw you, you screwed yourselves. Maybe next time you will not suspect of me so easily.

Also, there's the chance that there's another doctor, and i already told to the doctor to protect me, while i protect Chairdriver.

Now, its a matter of Hope.

That's not fair though. If we even have any doctors left, they're going to have to protect you every night because you made a bumbling error.

[Cube]

Also, there's the chance that there's another doctor, and i already told to the doctor to protect me, while i protect Chairdriver.

No. The other Doctor(s) can protect other people.

Chairdriver, I asked you last night but you didn't reply:

Are there any way in which your power won't work or the information is wrong?

[Eenuh]

Forget about info, damnit.

And Haggis, you problably missed that im a Doctor, you are making a big mistake by voting me.

And Gizmo, i didn't made any mistake yet, you are making the mistake, not me.

You made the biggest mistake possible by saying you're a doctor. Because now someone has to protect you every night, while they could be protecting an investigator. Which means that's one power lost due to your carelessness. If you were dead or alive, it wouldn't make a difference really. -____-;

[Vicar]

Who the hell is this thunderer is he a fresh meat or what and by the way no info here if I haven't mentioned that before

[MoogleViper]

Who the hell is this thunderer is he a fresh meat or what and by the way no info here if I haven't mentioned that before

Thunderer has been around quite a bit. He stole one of the mafia wins from me. Along with Mundi. Although I pretty much had Shino on my side.

[Tellyn]

Thunderer's quite the veteran, he's been in loads of games.

[Cube]

Vote: Thunderer

I can't see any good reasons to not lynch him.

[Jonnas]

Look, Maase always makes mistakes. It's natural. So, he is either telling the truth, or this is a diabolical scheme by the mafia to make Maase look fine.

We are voting Thunderer because he never participates, and remember the Thriller. You guys needed people to vote for Esequiel, but they never participated, so they didn't vote. I'd rather get rid of people who don't post, because Maase will at least vote for someone when need arises.

Thunderer's quite the veteran, he's been in loads of games.

One where he won because he was unlynchable, and the other he was the Godfather, but never participated.

[MadDog]

Vote:thunderer

Hes not posting so....

[Maase]

Hum, you're right Eenuh, well, i guess you lost one Doctor.

At least now you'l learn to have a good reason before lynching.

Anyway, i will protect Chairdriver anyway, if somebody helps me out due to charity, thank you, if you want to protect another, i will not be angry, i don't blame you

[MadDog]

I don't think Maase is telling the truth about him being a protector.
Sorry but i don't buy it.

[MoogleViper]

Me neither.

[Maase]

You know what?

If im screwed either way, and no one of you believes me, and you NEED to Lyunch someone (yeah right), lynch me then :\

Change Vote: Maase

Have fun, no one believes me, and frankly, im dead either way, so i don't care

[chairdriver]

Are there any way in which your power won't work or the information is wrong?

I dunno how Dyson has set the game up.

I mean, the mafia could have a msidirector or framer, so the info could be wrong.

There may be a roleblocker aswell.

[uəʌəsʎɐɾ]

Vote: Thunderer, because at the moment I think it's potentially safer to let Maase and Big C live under suspicion then kill either off, considering they're now mafia targets. Thunderer is usually fairly prolific with his mafia-playing, but he's dead-weight for this one. He probably signed up for it ages ago and has forgotten about it. Let's speed this up.

[Eenuh]

Since I agree that I'd rather have an active poster around.

Vote: Thunderer

[MoogleViper]

Fair enough

Vote:Thunderer

[Raining_again]

Where I'm still annoyed at maase taking the utter piss, I think it may not be worth lynching him (yet)

When you don't participate, and then win, it shouldn't count as a freakin' win.
I'm in agreement that the silent ones die. Thus;

Change vote: Thunderer.

[Tellyn]

Vote: Thunderer

For reasons which have been stated. Maase, it'd be good if you didn't reveal anything else about your role and how you use it. :/

[Jonnas]

I dunno how Dyson has set the game up.

I mean, the mafia could have a msidirector or framer, so the info could be wrong.

There may be a roleblocker aswell.

Didn't Dyson said that one or two investigators/doctors was all he would put in the game?

[Dyson]

The day will end at 9pm GMT.

[Eenuh]

How's the voting going?

[Coolness Bears]

VOTE: THUNDERER

[Jamba]

Just had a quick count through

Votes (17 Majority)
thunderer - 11 Votes (Jonnas, Esequiel, chairdriver, cube, MadDog, jayseven, Eenuh, MoogleViper, Raining_Again, Tellyn, Coolness Bears)
Maase - 7 votes (Shino, Gizmo, Zell, Jamba, the fish, Haggis, Maase)
No Lynch - 1 Vote (Brian McCoy)

[Slaggis]

Fair do's.

Change Vote: Thunderer

[Gizmo]

Fine.

Change Vote:Thunderer

And I wouldn't worry about protecting Maase tonight, doctors. The mafia won't want to kill him anyway.

[Jamba]

Change Vote: thunderer

[Eenuh]

Fine.

Change Vote:Thunderer

And I wouldn't worry about protecting Maase tonight, doctors. The mafia won't want to kill him anyway.

Eh? What do you mean?

[Maase]

Can you talk on behalf of the Mafia, or are you in Mafia and trying to kill me.

Well, if its anyone of those two, you can kill me, no one will protect me.

(I'l maintain my promise and protect Chairdriver, tough)

[mr-paul]

Because he's not participating I will VOTE: THUNDERER

I don't think Maase is evil. Just annoying.

[MoogleViper]

Because he's not participating I will VOTE: THUNDERER

I don't think Maase is evil. Just annoying.

To be honest I'm not sure which is worse.

[wildo]

Ok looks like I'm getting in before the 9pm deadline VOTE: THUNDERER.

Reason being that I feel it best we have active posters around although I am suspicious of Masse I still can't decide on him. It would be harsh to loose an important person early on.

[Tellyn]

Aaaand we're one vote short.

[Maase]

Too late, but ok

Change Vote: Thunderer

[Nintendohnut]

Well I would of voted but it seems you have majority now :)

Just in case Jamba miscounted (he probably didn't but in case)

Vote: Thunderer

[DomJcg]

vote: thunderer

*is confused*

[Dyson]

Day 2 is over.
---

The town decided that milling around was not acceptable; blood had been spilt, and this time it wasn't the poncy mayor that nobody gave a crap about Mayor, it was a fellow townie.

thunderer had never found these town debates very interesting, and as he slept, the town decided that he would be the one to go. He woke up dead.

thunderer is dead. He was a Mafia member.

As the crowd finished stabbing him with sporks, something shiny fell out of thunderers pocket; a bomb. The crowd dispersed, and the bomb exploded, but nobody was hurt.

--

Night 2 begins now. Do yer business.

[Shino]

If I were mafia, I would kill Maase myself.

Change Vote: Thunderer

Edit: I hate when this happens.

[chairdriver]

WOOO! We got a mafiosa!

I love when my gut feelings are right.

[Dyson]

Still waiting on a PM... :|

[MoogleViper]

It's been 24 hours. It's their loss.

[Nintendohnut]

Yeah just assume they want to spend the night sleeping.

...Unless it's a doctor or a policeman, in which case they need to get their ass in gear and you have to wait! :heh: Just carry on if it's a mafia member though :)

[Dyson]

Night 2 is over.

---

As the town slept, the Mafia discussed in detail their plans. "He's a slippery one," commented one of the members "but he's also tasty."

The town arose the next morning to find...

The fish is dead. He was good.

covered in tin foil with a skewer through his middle over a roasty toasty fire, almost ready to be served!

---

Day 3 starts...now! (16 is a majority)

[The fish]

Oh, penis.

I hope you all get food poisoning...

[Nintendohnut]

Right then Chair... what do you have for us? :heh:

Obviously no info here. Anyone willing to come forward with anything?

[chairdriver]

Lol @ the death scene!


Maase is clean folks, he's good.

[Cube]

I really hope that there is another protector.

I investigated Haggis last night. He is evil.

The first night I investigated Esequiel but Dyson sent the PM to him instead. He's good.

Vote: Haggis

[chairdriver]

Vote : Haggis

[MadDog]

Vote:Haggis
Lets put pressure on him

Vote:Haggis

Forgot bold :S

[darksnowman]

Evil? I'm willing to lynch evil.

Vote: Haggis

[Coolness Bears]

Evil aye!

VOTE: HAGGIS

[Eenuh]

If there is another protector, please protect Cube.


Vote: Haggis

[Gizmo]

Vote:Haggis

[LazyBoy]

Vote:Haggis

I'm interested to see how this game matures.

[Vicar]

Voting: haggis

You know my reason

[Tellyn]

Die you son of a - *BOOM!*

Vote: Haggis

[MoogleViper]

Vote: Haggis

[Jamba]

Ummm sorry guys, why are we trusting Cube now? We grilled chairdriver and now we aren't going to with him?

Or are we just going to wait till we kill Haggis and see what the outcome is?

[MoogleViper]

Kill haggis and then see if cube is right.

[Tellyn]

Well, Haggis doesn't post a lot, and we can easily lynch Cube if it doesn't work out.

[MoogleViper]

Also Dyson can you post a list of the players alive at the start of each night and day please.

[Slaggis]

I post enough, when I have info or to say if I don't. I have no idea why the hell your all so easy to trust Cube, just because hs says I'm evil. He could have easily picked a name at random and said "Oh , I'll say he's evil". It's like me going "Oh, Paj is evil, vote for him".

I'm not, I assure you. But there's bugger all else I can say. I've got no info to help either so if you want to vote for me I obviously can't stop you, but your voting for one of the good guys if you do.

[Eenuh]

I post enough, when I have info or to say if I don't. I have no idea why the hell your all so easy to trust Cube, just because hs says I'm evil. He could have easily picked a name at random and said "Oh , I'll say he's evil". It's like me going "Oh, Paj is evil, vote for him".

I'm not, I assure you. But there's bugger all else I can say. I've got no info to help either so if you want to vote for me I obviously can't stop you, but your voting for one of the good guys if you do.

Yeah but if his claim is wrong, then we know he was lying and have another lynch ready. Since there's only a couple of investigators in this game, this is all we can do really.

[MadDog]

I post enough, when I have info or to say if I don't. I have no idea why the hell your all so easy to trust Cube, just because he says I'm evil. He could have easily picked a name at random and said "Oh , I'll say he's evil". It's like me going "Oh, Paj is evil, vote for him".

I'm not, I assure you. But there's bugger all else I can say. I've got no info to help either so if you want to vote for me I obviously can't stop you, but your voting for one of the good guys if you do.

Well how do we know we can believe you then when you say your good?

[MoogleViper]

I post enough, when I have info or to say if I don't. I have no idea why the hell your all so easy to trust Cube, just because hs says I'm evil. He could have easily picked a name at random and said "Oh , I'll say he's evil". It's like me going "Oh, Paj is evil, vote for him".

I'm not, I assure you. But there's bugger all else I can say. I've got no info to help either so if you want to vote for me I obviously can't stop you, but your voting for one of the good guys if you do.

Evil people always say that.

Anyway it would be unwise for a mafia member to put himself at risk so early in the game. And as eenuh said if he's wrong then we'll lynch him tomorrow.

[Slaggis]

Evil people always say that.

Anyway it would be unwise for a mafia member to put himself at risk so early in the game. And as eenuh said if he's wrong then we'll lynch him tomorrow.

Oh great, so I'm ebing voted for just because some random guy says so. Wonderful - how about some real evidence that can be backed up rather than you trusting a someone just because they say I'm "evil".

[Jamba]

Yeah Haggis, it's harsh mate but they do have a point and I'm suspcious of Cube still but this is one of the quickest ways for townies to get some facts.

[Eenuh]

Oh great, so I'm ebing voted for just because some random guy says so. Wonderful - how about some real evidence that can be backed up rather than you trusting a someone just because they say I'm "evil".

That's the thing, we can't get more evidence than what people find out through investigating. There's nothing else to go on in this game.

[Cube]

There is no chance that my information is wrong. The mafia has no misdirectors, roleblockers or anything of the sort.

If I was part of the mafia and was just pretending to be an investigator then that would be quite stupid - as the mafia is smaller, trading one mafia member for one good guy isn't exactly a good idea.

[Jamba]

Oh great, so I'm ebing voted for just because some random guy says so. Wonderful - how about some real evidence that can be backed up rather than you trusting a someone just because they say I'm "evil".

But that's the problem. This is a Bare Bones Mafia. There is very little info to go on. Almost everyone in the game has no power at all so there are very few ways of getting info. This is all that we are likely to get.

[Slaggis]

But it's like me saying "Cubes Evil - I found out last night". So vote for him.

Anyway, I obviosuly can't change people's minds, so whatever. I'm good, thats about all I can say.

[Jamba]

But it's like me saying "Cubes Evil - I found out last night". So vote for him.


But that would be a stupid thing to do if you were evil. Everyone would vote and find out that that person you condemned was good, then they'd kill you the next day for it. A pretty short-sighted strategy.

[Nintendohnut]

I agree with Cube and Jamba. It's a bit pointless revealing yourself with info when it's clearly going to be proven right or wrong at the end of the day. It makes more sense to find out if he is trustworthy. Incidentally the fact that there should only be a small mafia means that if we lynch both of you and only one of you is mafia, that's a bonus.

Shit forgot to

Vote: Haggis

[Shino]

I believe Cube.

Vote: Haggis

[Zell]

Vote: Haggis

[Mundi]

Vote: Haggis
I have nothing to conflict that

[wildo]

Apart from Cube saying Haggis is a bad guy, do we have anything else to go by?

[Jamba]

D'oh... forgot to vote:

Vote: Haggis

[DomJcg]

Vote: Haggis

Not sure if it's worth lynching someone just to find out if cubes lying or not. I personally think the investigators are chair and shino...but i'm aware it the only way forward.

[Tellyn]

I didn't play Chair's early mafia games so I'm unsure about this: do the mafia have kidnappers (or similar roles) at their disposal which could result in them forcing Cube to do their bidding?

I'll remove my vote for now. He must be fairly close to a lynch, maybe we can get some sort of information from Haggis if we don't hang him immediately. If we don't get any other sort of evidence from any other investigators (if there are any), then we'll let him fry.

[Gizmo]

Tellyn are you seriously going to be that cautious?

What can we get from Haggis? If he was a protector/investigator he'd have already said so to try and defend himself. If he's a normal good guy he would have nothing to add. If he was evil he wouldn't add anything anyway.

[Tellyn]

Good point.

Vote: Haggis

[wildo]

Ah lets just get this thing done Vote: Haggis. Why waste a day.

[Maase]

Chairdriver, thanks for clearing that :)

Vote: Haggis:

Sorry, even tough you're right about that, Cube has no reason to lie, because this is a Bare Bones Mafia.

[Jonnas]

Vote: Haggis

And one more thing, from a few comments here, I have a feeling Jamba might be evil. Just a hunch, though.

[Cube]

I didn't play Chair's early mafia games so I'm unsure about this: do the mafia have kidnappers (or similar roles) at their disposal which could result in them forcing Cube to do their bidding?

There's a possibility that I'll be unable to investigate on certain nights (I'm sure chairdriver knows about that, too), but my information can't be wrong or forced or anything.

The mafia only has one person with a power. And that power is to kill.

[Jamba]

Vote: Haggis

And one more thing, from a few comments here, I have a feeling Jamba might be evil. Just a hunch, though.

Dude... :(

[DomJcg]

There's a possibility that I'll be unable to investigate on certain nights (I'm sure chairdriver knows about that, too), but my information can't be wrong or forced or anything.

The mafia only has one person with a power. And that power is to kill.

Dude

Your wrong, remember thunderer yesterday? he had a bomb on him...i think they have more powers than we know.

[MoogleViper]

Dude

Your wrong, remember thunderer yesterday? he had a bomb on him...i think they have more powers than we know.

But nobody died so I don't think it was much use if any at all.

[DomJcg]

But nobody died so I don't think it was much use if any at all.

But, if he had no power why was it noted at all?

[MoogleViper]

But, if he had no power why was it noted at all?

I'm not saying he didn't have a power I'm just saying it's probably not going to be as powerful as other mafia games.

[Jonnas]

Dude... :(

As I said, just a hunch. Don't take it too seriously. Just the typical mafia suspicion.

[Esequiel]

Vote haggis

[Fandango]

Vote: Haggis

Hope Cube is right.

[Tellyn]

Dude

Your wrong, remember thunderer yesterday? he had a bomb on him...i think they have more powers than we know.

And the mafia made a kill again during the night, so Thunderer clearly wasn't their killer. For a game which is intentionally simple, it brings so much paranoia. :(

[Oxigen_Waste]

I'm not really gonna vote coz I haven't read anyting since it started. Will do so as soon as possible.

[Raining_again]

Nothing to report here. Surely the majority has been reached by now?